Mystic, Connecticut: Pizza… and So Much More

Mystic, Connecticut: Pizza… and So Much More

Mystic, about the midpoint between NYC and Boston, is a fantastic getaway. In less than a two-hour drive, our family left the sweltering heat of the city for some quiet time in this quaint riverside community. Long before Julia Roberts and Co. made Mystic famous with a little film about a local pizza place (more about that in just a bit), Mystic was a shipbuilding town — there’s a rich history here to enjoy along with a sunset sail and walks along the river.

Where To Eat

Toasted Tofu Salad at The Engine Room

Toasted Tofu Salad at The Engine Room

The Engine Room

This rustic, romantic spot was the perfect place to celebrate my wedding anniversary. I’m not usually especially jazzed about tofu, but my Smoked Tofu Salad (quinoa, spinach, mint, roasted carrots, toasted peanuts & ginger apricot dressing) was one of the best salads I’ve had in a long time. My husband Seth opted for the Crispy Tofu Burger, and there’s also a Portobello Burger on the menu. Definitely start with the Black-Eyed Pea Hummus, served with crispy sesame flatbread.

The Oyster Club

Sister restaurant of The Engine Room, a little more upscale and intimate. When we made our reservation, we gave them a heads up the vegans were coming, though there is a salad and entree that are already do-able. When we arrived, however, the chef wanted to surprise us a bit. So, in lieu of the salad on the menu as a starter, we were served fresh blueberries and basil drizzled with olive oil, and then an equally simple but bursting-with-flavor tomato salad. The entree — available on the regular menu — was a delicious mild tofu curry. If you’re up for a cocktail, I recommend a classic martini made with a local Connecticut vodka.

The Treehouse (at The Oyster Club)

Reservation for 8pm at the Oyster Club? Head over early to allow yourself time for a drink at The Treehouse beforehand. You’ll climb the wooden stairs to an expansive deck area situated in the treetops — a little playful, a little magical — for a beer, a glass of vine or perhaps even a fruity cocktail. If you’re visiting Mystic, this one-of-a-kind place is not to be missed.

The Boathouse

A casual atmosphere, with a delicious black bean burger on the menu. We topped ours with sauteed mushrooms and carmelized onions. A nice (and inexpensive) meal, and also very family-friendly: a great choice if you’re traveling with kids or a group.

Strawberry Basil Bruschetta at Noca

Strawberry Basil Bruschetta at Noca


In the heart of downtown, just a stroll away from the drawbridge across the Mystic River. We had a wonderful lunch here, lured in by the Strawberry Basil Bruschetta on the menu, which did not disappoint. We then split a Veggie Panini that was absolutely de-lish: the grilled zucchini, squash, and roasted peppers were cooked just right — not squishy and soggy! And there was a light schmear of black bean hummus on the fresh, slightly crispy bread. I know a veggie panini may not sound particularly exciting but, trust me, this is the way it’s meant to be done.


Vegan Pie at Mystic

Mystic Pizza

You knew it was coming. How could you visit Mystic and not go to the pizza place that inspired the 1980s Julia Roberts flick? No, the interior looks nothing like the interior of the place in the movie; and even the exterior shots are of a different building, though the film was shot around Mystic. And no, Mystic Pizza is not offering up a bunch of vegan options. But they were happy to veganize the Vegetarian Pie on the menu: hold the cheese and use marinara instead of the usual pizza sauce. The two-story restaurant — no surprise — is very busy (I’m guessing mostly tourists), service is very friendly, and it’s very fun to watch scenes from the movie (TV screens in the rooms) as you enjoy “a slice of heaven.”

Pesto Splash at Pizzetta

Pesto Splash at Pizzetta


So here’s the pizza joint with all the vegan goodies. Lightlife and Gardein products are listed on the separate vegetarian menu that offers all sorts of specialty pies and sandwiches. Meatless meatballs, sausage, and “chicken” are all here. So is vegan Daiya cheese. Lunch or dinner here is a completely different pizza experience from one at Mystic: the thin pie crust is light and crispy; the large patio dining out back is dog-friendly, so our Galileo got to enjoy some pizza with us. Our choice of pie? The Pesto Splash, a “white” pie lightly brushed with pesto, sprinkled with Daiya, and topped with fresh diced tomatoes.

Mystic Market

Eat in or take out at this cozy little market. Although the deli area has a couple of veg sandwiches and wraps made to order, we decided to create a plate by choosing from a variety of prepared salads. My plate: wakame salad, Asian cabbage slaw, and roasted sweet potatoes with black beans. Seth was in the mood for a heavier lunch of vegan dumplings and noodles.

The Pita Stop

We didn’t have time to make our own stop here, but I believe it’s always important to know where one can get a falafel in town, should she have a hankering…

Where To Stay:

Galileo on the Mystic River Promenade

Galileo on the Mystic River Promenade

Hyatt Park Place

We always want to make sure our family vacation is a comfortable, relaxing, and fun experience for our Galileo, too. Most times, we’ll opt for a dog-friendly B&B. For this trip, we went with a more conventional hotel experience. A couple of the days we were visiting were particularly warm and humid, which meant Galileo stayed in the cool air-conditioned room for a lot of the day, whether with us or while we were out exploring. The dog-friendly rooms at The Hyatt ($75 non-refundable fee) include a separate sitting and kitchen area, so he had plenty of space to move around.

Kudos to the hotel for being human-friendly, too — more specifically, vegan-friendly. The complimentary breakfast buffet had quite a few options for us, from fresh fruit and cereal to oatmeal with all the fixins. It’s disappointing that the hotel does not yet offer nondairy milk along with its breakfast; but after we asked about it on our first morning there, a staff member bought both soy and almond milk for us (delivered it to our room, to keep in our fridge). Now, I’d just like to see them have it available for all the guests as a usual thing…

The Charles W. Morgan at Mystic Seaport

The Charles W. Morgan

Where To Play:

Mystic Seaport, Museum of America and the Sea

A main attraction in Mystic is its Aquarium. However, as an animal rights advocate, I strongly urge you not to support this kind of use of animals. Steer clear of the aquarium! If you’re interested in seeing marine life, keep driving north and get yourself to Cape Cod, where you can see dolphins and whales in the protected Stellwagen Bank Sanctuary.

The Mystic Seaport Museum, on the other hand, is a must for the to-do list. It’s a bit pricey ($25 for an adult ticket) but that one ticket gets you into quite an impressive set of exhibits and attractions, everything from old ships to the recreation of an 1800s village and shipyard. I was particularly interested to see the last surviving wooden whaling ship, the Charles W. Morgan: as I walked through the rooms of the ship, I was reminded of my Literature days spent poring over Melville; I also was feeling very thankful for the Marine Mammal Protection Act of 1972, which protects marine mammals (including whales) within U.S. waters.

East Beach

East Beach

East Beach (Westerly/Watch Hill)

For some beach time, I highly recommend taking the short drive (25 minutes) to nearby Watch Hill, Rhode Island. The surrounding neighborhood is beautiful, kind of a smaller-scale Newport; the water is clear and not too rough, so swimmers of all ages can enjoy the day. Find your parking near the center of town and the Watch Hill & Carousel Beach; then walk up the street towards The Ocean House, where you’ll find a short path to the free public East Beach. Less hectic than the shoreline at the carousel, it’s the perfect place to relax, build a sand castle, and soak up the sunshine.